Samantha, a podcast host who takes music as seriously as she does love stands in on a so-called frivolous love songs podcast. When Jake, a sentimental romantic calls the show in search of a lost love, she seizes the opportunity to prove herself professionally by promising to help him find her. But when she falls for the man she's been trying to help, she must choose between saving her beloved indie music podcast or admitting her true feelings and calling off the search. It's not long before she's let go of her show, along with her belief that there's a right way to find Mr. Right.